Landmarks, Landowners, News Desk, Ranchland

Land Report 100er: The Butler Family

ButlerFamily1_lg

For Over a Century, Shepherding a Spanish Land Grant
Has Been This Family’s Legacy.

Benjamin Franklin Butler (1818–93), a Massachusetts politician and Union Civil War general, was also a forward-thinking landman whose legacy ranch, now in its fifth and sixth generations, comes complete with a colorful history. While serving in Congress Butler met Thomas Benton Catron, a lawyer who would later serve as the first senator from the State of New Mexico. Catron was the largest landowner in the West at the time, having bought several Mexican land grants. He and a partner had formed the Santa Fe Ring to control economic and political life in New Mexico, and in 1870 they established an investment pool to buy land in the Mora Land Grant. Since there were no surveys or titles, Ring members would buy a partial interest from people working the land whose only claim was a share of community common lands.

Benjamin F. Butler
Benjamin F. Butler

When the pool disbanded, members sought buyers for their shares, and both Butler and his son-in-law, Adelbert Ames, began to purchase interests in the Mora Grant. In 1885, Butler and Catron met in New York, and supposedly, after a negotiation that went far into the night, Butler agreed to buy Catron’s share in the Mora Grant. According to family chronicles compiled by Edward (Ned) Ames, one of the Butler heirs, whatever agreement may have been reached at that meeting, there is no record of Butler’s ever having closed the deal. What followed was a litigious dispute with Catron suing Butler for his alleged failure to pay for his interests in the Mora Grant, and Butler persuading the court to have Catron removed as the attorney for a separate, ongoing suit over the partitioning of the unallocated common lands of the Mora Grant.
Of course, this era was rife with litigation over land matters; there were large financial stakes over the control of property interests, and since there were few surveys or deeds and much manipulation, nobody could be sure of who owned what land.
As the nineteenth century drew to a close, the New Mexico Territory was beset by competing legal claims to massive Spanish land grants. Butler held his land interests in the Union Land and Grazing Company, which he established in 1885. The Fort Union Ranch, now a 95,315-acre working cattle ranch near Watrous, is crossed by traces of the Santa Fe Trail and surrounds the Fort Union National Monument. The monument was actually a part of the ranch until 1954. The fort was a frequent way station for Kit Carson, and during the Civil War the Confederacy’s goal of conquering the Southwest hinged on seizing Fort Union. The CSA’s ill-fated New Mexico Campaign came to an end 60 miles from Fort Union at the Battle of Glorieta Pass. The fort was abandoned after the war, and almost a century later a grassroots effort ensued to save the fort’s structures. Private citizens and the New Mexico Department of Transportation purchased 720 acres from the Butlers.
As the nineteenth century drew to a close, the New Mexico Territory was beset by competing legal claims to massive Spanish land grants.
As the nineteenth century drew to a close, the New Mexico Territory was beset by competing legal claims to massive Spanish land grants.

“From there, all it took was President Eisenhower to sign the enabling legislation and the monument was created,” says Ron Harvey, lead interpretive ranger for the Fort Union National Monument. “It’s actually almost fitting that you have this cattle ranch around Fort Union Monument. One could not have survived without the other.”
The Fort Union Ranch is managed by five directors, including Ames, all descendants of General Butler. Ranching operations are run by Ken Lausten, a graduate of Colorado State School of Agriculture, who came to the ranch from California in 2011. The land’s diverse operations include a cow-calf herd, seasonal grazing by up to 1,800 pasture cattle, annual elk and pronghorn hunts, and timber and whole-tree harvest. The family owns an additional 6,000 undesignated acres in Mora County.
In partnership with the Sonoran Institute, Fort Union Ranch has developed an integrated plan for range management. The drought of 2011 was the impetus. The goal, according to Ames, was to establish an ecologically sensitive program that would allow for cattle grazing, protect wildlife, and restore natural habitat. One of the outcomes of the effort has been the creation of the High Plains Grasslands Alliance, a new collaboration.
“Our interest now is really focused on how to run the ranch successfully in a sustainable way,” says Ames. “It’s been some time since ranchers could support themselves solely on the basis of a cow/calf operation. We have to assume that these periodic droughts that have happened are going to become more frequent. So managing that trend is a challenge; it changes the way we raise cattle and manage the landscape. Whether or not you buy the whole thesis and theory of global climate change, if you’re a land manager, you’ve got to be prepared.”

READ MORE
Please sign me up to receive breaking news and updates from The Land Report:
Print & Gift
Subscriptions Available

RELATED ARTICLES

Estates

The Investment Issue: America’s Finest Hunting Lodge

Matchless Hunting Combines Old World Hospitality Just East of Dallas   Set high above two …

Landowners

2015 Land Report 100: Hunt Family

No. 50 Hunt Family 200,000 acres The history of Hunt Oil Company dates back to …

Archives

The Land Report Fall 2013

With 2.2 million acres, John Malone takes top honors for the third consecutive year. His love of land, coupled with his wife’s love of horses, led to several key acquisitions, including a historic Irish castle just south of Dublin and two properties in Wellington, the epicenter of Florida’s equestrian community.
At more than 2 million acres, Ted Turner runs a close second to his good friend. Turner enjoys the distinction of being New Mexico’s largest landowner, and he capitalized on that honor by acquiring the historic Sierra Grande Lodge and Spa in Truth or Consequences. Guests at the Lodge will be able to enjoy tours of Turner’s 156,439-acre Ladder Ranch and his 362,885-acre Armendaris Ranch.
Thanks to his acquisition of the Broken O Ranch, Denver Nuggets owner Stan Kroenke moved up from No. 10 on last year’s list to No. 8 in the rankings. Among the newcomers to this year’s list are Texas’s Wilks Brothers, founders of Frac Tech. Their prized jewel is Montana’s 60,000-acre N Bar Ranch, which they acquired from former Land Report 100er Tom Siebel, founder of Siebel Systems. Another new name on the list is Arthur Nicholas, who serves on the board of the National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum. Nicholas is the owner of Wyoming’s historic Wagonhound Land and Livestock Co., which is the subject of a new book by Land Reporters Wyman Meinzer and Henry Chappell.
We invite you to be among the first to view the complete rundown of America’s top landowners, which is available exclusively on the Fay Ranches website. Click here to download your PDF today.

LR ForestParkRanch 18
Ranchland Portfolio

Forest Park Ranch

Forest Park Ranch encompasses 2,215 deeded acres of exceptional well-maintained land and has all the …